The Trump Effect Heads Abroad: European CEOs Are Getting Ousted
As President Donald Trump amplifies his trade war with multiple countries, it sends a strong signal to European CEOs struggling to match their U.S. counterparts: their time is running out. Recent momentum in European markets, combined with a long-standing disappointment over underperforming shares and renewed interest from activist investors, indicates that executives are operating in an increasingly precarious environment. A recent high-profile departure underscores this trend.
Unilever on the Hot Seat
Take the case of Unilever, a consumer goods giant with brands like Dove soap, Persil detergent, and Ben & Jerry’s ice cream in its portfolio. Just last month, Unilever’s Board announced the ousting of Chief Executive Officer Hein Schumacher after a brief tenure of less than two years. The news comes amid a backdrop of disappointing share performance, as Unilever’s stock has slumped 7% over the past six months while the U.K.’s FTSE 100 has risen by 3% during the same timeframe. Unilever’s Board acknowledged that while they were pleased with the company’s performance in 2024, there remains a pressing need to strive for “best-in-class results.”
Following Schumacher’s departure, the company appointed its Chief Financial Officer, Fernando Fernandez, as the new CEO. Fernandez previously oversaw Unilever’s health and wellbeing unit, which ranks as one of its fastest-growing sectors. Almost immediately, he announced plans to expedite the divestment of smaller European food brands, indicating a strategic pivot in response to investor dissatisfaction. Notably, activist investor Nelson Peltz, who sits on Unilever’s board and has held a stake since 2022, publicly supported the leadership change.
Other High-Profile Departures
Unilever is not alone in facing leadership upheaval. French engineering company Schneider Electric parted ways with its CEO after just 18 months in November. Similarly, Nestlé saw its leader, Mark Schneider, exit last August after an extended period that ended with a stock decline of over 20%. This event occurred prior to Trump’s election but still aligned with a significant dip following a pandemic-driven peak.
Scrutiny and Strategic Revisions
With European markets struggling to keep pace, scrutiny on European corporations has intensified. Martin Todd, a portfolio manager for Sustainable Global Equity at Federated Hermes, noted, “Given the underperformance of European markets versus the U.S., there will inevitably be scrutiny on European corporates to deliver.” This scrutiny could manifest in various forms, including expedited restructuring efforts, changes in capital allocation, or strategic reassessments in companies across the continent.
More CEOs Under Pressure
Murray Auchincloss, CEO of BP, recently announced a “fundamental reset” in the company’s strategy as it continues to lag behind U.S. competitors like Exxon and Chevron. With activist firm Elliott Management holding a stake and advocating for transformation, BP finds itself in a similar situation of pressure to perform.
Valuation Discrepancies
For some time, European companies have been overshadowed by their U.S. peers, with significant disparities in P/E ratios. In the fourth quarter, the STOXX Europe 600 had an average price/earnings ratio of 16, while the S&P 500 stood at a remarkable 28. Various contributing factors include weaker economic growth in Europe, a market more resistant to risk, and the absence of groundbreaking tech firms that have propelled U.S. stock performance.
A Sea Change Hits European Markets
However, recent changes stemming from Trump’s pronouncements may be shifting the tide. His inclination to impose tariffs on Europe following measures on Mexico, Canada, and China shows a decisive move to retract American collaboration and lend weight to European defense budgets. Consequently, Germany announced plans for the most substantial increase in state spending in decades, with the European Union calling for rearmament efforts. This rise in defense spending is mirroring improved performances in European stock markets, which have outpaced those in the U.S. this year.
Furthermore, corporate earnings are showing signs of recovery. Maximilian Uleer, a strategist at Deutsche Bank, reported a 10% increase in earnings for STOXX 600 companies (excluding energy) in the fourth quarter—marking the best performance in two years. He optimistically forecasts continued earnings recovery into 2025.
Activist Investors on the Rise
As European stocks rebound under these circumstances, American activist investors are increasingly eyeing opportunities across the Atlantic. In 2024, the share of activist campaigns in Europe attributed to American funds surged to 35% from 27% the previous year. Alvarez & Marsal anticipates further transatlantic campaigning, especially among industrial and consumer firms, through 2025 and 2026.
In conclusion, the prospect of a robust recovery in European markets presents investors with opportunities to reap rewards from the resurgence of companies that have previously performed below expectations. For European CEOs, there’s no time for complacency, as scrutiny from investors looms larger than ever.